J.J. McCarthy named starter for Giants: What could it mean for the fantasy outlooks of Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely?
The Giants are turning to J.J. McCarthy at quarterback. How should fantasy managers feel about the move?
TE · NYG · 26 yrs · exp 4 · Coastal Carolina
From latest snapshot · trend vs ~7d prior when data allows.
One snapshot point per calendar day (shown in your timezone).
Latest: Oct 22, 2026 · 5,553
Stories linked to this player — newest first.
The Giants are turning to J.J. McCarthy at quarterback. How should fantasy managers feel about the move?
J.J. McCarthy will be the Giants starter in their Week 7 matchup against Houston. The Giants have benched Jameis Winston in favor of the younger McCarthy, who came to the Giants via trade with Minnesota a couple weeks ago. McCarthy has his flaws, some of which were on full display in the Giants comeback attempt against the Saints. However, he also nearly brought them back to a win, so it sounds like the coaching staff has decided the benefits outweigh the risks. Expect Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely to continue to be force fed targets, with smaller shares going to Malachi Fields, Darnell Mooney, and the like
Ravens Snap Count Analysis, Week 6: Rookie pass-catchers flash but offense struggles
J.J. McCarthy made a strong case to replace Jameis Winston as the Giants' starting quarterback after an impressive showing in relief. Winston was benched after throwing two interceptions, and McCarthy led three scoring drives to nearly force overtime, throwing for 243 yards, one touchdown, and one interception. The Giants, currently atop the NFC East, face a decision on who should lead the offense going forward
Giants head coach John Harbaugh is hesitant to make a decision on his quarterback for Week 7, following a strong performance from J.J. McCarthy in relief
The Saints escaped a potential upset against the Giants, winning 34-27 behind a late surge
Giants bench Jameis Winston for J.J. McCarthy in 4th quarter of Week 6 matchup against Saints
Isaiah Likely is proving his worth with the Giants, ranking second among NFL tight ends with 33 catches after leaving Mark Andrews' shadow
Abdul Carter out of practice for Giants Wednesday due to calf injury
Week 5 of the NFL season has come and gone, and we have a good sample size of snaps so far, including from rookies. Seven teams had more than one pick in the first round of the 2026 draft: Jets , Browns , Titans , Chiefs , Giants , Cowboys and Dolphins . So, how are those rookie classes performing in relation to others? There are several ways to measure and weigh the impact of rookie performers, but there is no substitute for playing time. Before getting into the teams whose rookies have played the most, the five lowest snap totals belong to the Broncos (63), Rams (194), Seahawks (283), Eagles (403) and Cardinals (545). Here are the rookie classes that have played the most snaps this season: Baltimore's rookie class is headlined by offensive lineman Vega Ioane. He was playing right guard but was forced to start at center in Week 5, and the acquisition of Cam Jurgens will allow the Ravens to get the five best linemen on the field. Ioane is allowing pressure for every 32.4 pass blocking snaps, according to TruMedia. Rookie tight ends Matthew Hibner and Josh Cuevas have helped the franchise absorb the losses of Isaiah Likely and Charlie Kolar . Wide receiver Ja'Kobi Lane saw a significant workload in Week 1, but was then lost for the season due to injury. Cornerback Chandler Rivers and edge rushers Zion Young and Ethan Burke have also factored into the defensive rotation. New York made two selections in the top-10 overall: linebacker Arvell Reese and right guard Francis Mauigoa . Those two players have accounted for more than half of the Giants' rookie snap counts. Additionally, 22% of the rookie snap count has been played on special teams. Reese has looked the part through five games. Mauigoa is allowing a pressure once every 18.7 pass blocking snaps, according to TruMedia. Cornerback Colton Hood has started two games for the team. Wide receiver Malachi Fields has been an asset in both the run and the pass. I wrote about Fields as one of the non-first-round picks who have taken on a large role this season. Los Angeles is off to an unforeseen and uncharacteristic 0-5 start. The team's issues go well beyond injuries, but those, too, have taken a toll. When veteran center Tyler Biadasz suffered a season-ending injury prior to the season, it forced Day 2 selection Jake Slaughter into the starting lineup. Slaughter is allowing a pressure for every 25.7 pass blocking snaps, according to TruMedia. Ten rookies have taken offensive or defensive snaps for the Chargers this season. Of the 612 offensive snaps, five offensive linemen have combined for all but 22. Safety Genesis Smith and edge rusher Akheem Mesidor are fully immersed in the defensive rotation. All of Cleveland's top-100 overall selections have delivered thus far. Spencer Fano and Austin Barber are starting at left tackle and right guard, respectively. Fano is allowing a pressure for every 23.1 pass blocking snaps, according to TruMedia. Barber is allowing a pressure for every 46.3 pass blocking snaps. Wide receivers Denzel Boston and KC Concepcion rank in the top three on the team in each of the following receiving categories: receptions, yards and targets. Safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren has seen his role expand with each passing week. His length and aggressiveness playing downhill have allowed the team to be more creative with personnel and blitz packages. McNeil-Warren often takes on the role of playing single high when the team opts for it. Cleveland's five other draft selections have a combined 118 snaps; all but three of which have come on special teams. Miami is on pace for 7,106 rookie snaps played this season, which is just off the pace for the most played in a season over the last decade. The Browns' 2016 rookie class played 7,185 snaps during a 16-game season. I previously wrote about that Browns class and other high-volume rookie classes over the last decade. Linebacker Jacob Rodriguez leads all NFL players with 57 tackles. He, along with safety Mich [... truncated ...]
The Giants trailed by 14 points in the fourth quarter, but the Commanders could not put them away. Jameis Winston threw a pair of touchdown passes, including a game-tying score to Malik Nabers with 1:43 to play and the Commanders’ ensuing drive died near midfield, so the two teams are going to overtime with the score tied at 27. Jayden Daniels ran for two scores in the second half to stretch the Commanders’ lead to 14 points, but Winston finally found his form after struggling in the rain for much of the day. He has thrown two scores to tight end Isaiah Likely in addition to the one to Nabers and is 28-of-44 for 283 yards overall. The Giants have all the momentum, but they’ll need to do what the Commanders couldn’t by finishing the job in the extra period
J.J. McCarthy made his Giants debut on the team’s first offensive possession in Washington. McCarthy came off the bench one play after Jameis Winston converted a third-and-13 with a 15-yard pass to tight end Isaiah Likely. He threw a quick pass to wide receiver Darnell Mooney that went for a five-yard loss, although the Giants wound up moving forward thanks to a facemask penalty. Winston returned to the game on the next play and the Giants wound up trying a 50-yard field goal a few snaps later. Dominic Zvada missed the kick and the Commanders are still up 6-0 with 7:11 to play in the first quarter
Giants WR Malik Nabers cleared for Sunday, with no injury designation, while several teammates remain sidelined
Knee soreness kept Malik Nabers off the field on Wednesday, but the Giants wide receiver was back at work on Thursday. Nabers was a limited participant as the Giants continued preparing to face the Commanders in Week 5. Nabers was noncommittal about his status for the game when he spoke to reporters Wednesday, but the return to work is a good sign that he’ll be able to go. Left tackle Andrew Thomas (groin) also returned on a limited basis. The Giants have managed Thomas’s practice workload all season without him missing any game action. Running back Najee Harris (personal) was a full participant after missing the first practice of the week. Defensive lineman Chauncey Golston (neck) and safety Jason Pinnock (concussion) remained out of practice. Tight end Isaiah Likely (knee, groin), tight end Chris Manhertz (shoulder), and running back Cam Skattebo (shoulder) were limited for the second straight day. Cornerback Deonte Banks (calf) and offensive lineman Bryan Hudson (ankle) were both full participants
Malik Nabers out of practice due to knee soreness, among others
Sleeper status change for Isaiah Likely (8131). Before: status=Active, injury_status=—. After: status=Active, injury_status=Questionable
The NFL’s announcement of fines for Week 3 featured six infractions for player safety fouls that qualify toward possible suspensions. Two of those fouls were hip-drop tackles. 49ers linebacker Fred Warner and Rams safety Kam Curl were each fined $17,911. Warner was also fined $23,882 for illegal use of his helmet in a tackle. Texans linebacker Jamal Hill, Giants tight end Isaiah Likely, and Steelers linebacker Cole Holcomb were each fined for blindside blocks. Texans linebacker Azeez Al-Shaair was fined for a hit on a defenseless player. Any player with three fines for any one of those infractions will be suspended for one game. The same potential penalty applies to fouls for launching or horse-collar tackles. No player has been fined more than once for any of the qualifying infractions yet this season
J.J. McCarthy will wear No. 18 instead of No. 9 in New York
After winning two Super Bowl championships with Eli Manning at quarterback, it appears the New York Giants franchise and their fans are cursed to be the NFL's Sisyphus, pushing the boulder, which represents their hopes, up and down the NFL's hill for eternity. New York went five postseason-less years after Manning's last playoff game in 2016, a crushing 38-13 defeat in the NFC wild card round at the Green Bay Packers , before coming close to climbing the hill in 2022. That's when quarterback Daniel Jones and running back Saquon Barkley helped lead the Giants to a 31-24 wild-card round road upset of the NFC North champion Minnesota Vikings . The crash back down came once again the following week with a 38-7 divisional round defeat at the Eagles that revealed exactly how far away that iteration of the Giants truly was from contending. Fast forward to 2026, and the Giants had hope once again. Things appeared to be different with New York's offensive core of second-year quarterback Jaxson Dart , Pro Bowl wide receiver Malik Nabers , bowling ball running back Cam Skattebo and tight end Isaiah Likely under new Super Bowl-winning head coach John Harbaugh. They punched the Dallas Cowboys , a longtime New York bully under quarterback Dak Prescott , in the mouth in a physical, 28-20 "Sunday Night Football" victory in which they limited Prescott's high-flying offense to just two drives in the second half. The Giants won the time of possession battle 36:40 to 23:20 after converting on 9 of their 11 third downs, with one of Dallas' "stops" being the kneel down on the game's final play. That stood as New York's most efficient, single-game third-down production since 1978. After a 28-6 Week 2 defeat on "Monday Night Football" against the Los Angeles Rams , the boulder has come crashing down once again. Dart exited the game with a knee injury that was initially believed to be a sprained MCL. Now, ESPN reported the 23-year-old could miss "an extended period of time, possibly the season" after testing came back worse than anticipated. Harbaugh said, via ESPN, on Tuesday , that "evaluations are ongoing" and that the team has "learned a lot more." It's a shame given the promise Dart flashed: he is the only quarterback in NFL history with 18-plus passing touchdowns (18) and 9-plus (9) rushing touchdowns in his first 14 career starts, per CBS Sports Research. In the Week 1 victory over Dallas, Dart became just the third quarterback in Giants history with 3-plus passing touchdowns (3) and 50-plus rushing yards (54) in a game, joining Phil Simms (1988) and Fran Tarkenton (1967 and 1968). Unfortunately for New York, it appeared the injury bug was going to bite Dart sooner or later, as it has every Giants primary starting quarterback post-Manning. He has been evaluated in the blue medical tent in 44% of his NFL starts, including the preseason, per CBS Sports Research. Dart's previous six blue tent visits were for concussion evaluation before his knee injury sidelined him on Monday night. Manning once made 210 consecutive regular-season starts, but both quarterbacks New York has drafted in the first round in an attempt to replace him as their franchise quarterback, Jones and Dart, haven't been able to stay healthy. In the one year Jones was fully healthy in 2022, New York reached the divisional round. Dart missed two games with a concussion a year ago, and there's a chance he doesn't play again this season. Daniel Jones (2019) 2 Sprained ankle Daniel Jones (2020) 2 Hamstring, ankle Daniel Jones (2021) 6 Neck Daniel Jones (2022) 1 Rest in Week 18 Daniel Jones (2023) 11 Neck, torn ACL Daniel Jones (2024) 7 Benched and released after 10 starts Jaxson Dart (2025) 2 Concussion Jaxson Dart (2026) Potentially out for the season Knee Now, the Giants (1-1) will turn to 2015 NFL Draft first overall pick Jameis Winston at the age of 32-years-old. New York re-signed him to a $13.5 million extension with $12.24 million guaranteed on Sep [... truncated ...]
The Los Angeles Rams have had 10 days to recover from their season-opening loss to the San Francisco 49ers in Australia, a 27-7 setback in which star offseason acquisition Myles Garrett was ineffective due to an injured knee that he had surgically repaired last week and landed him on injured reserve. Fellow pass-rushing virtuoso Aaron Donald is expected to make his season debut in Week 2 of the 2026 NFL season, but the Rams could be without wide receiver Puka Nacua because of a hip injury. Make your Monday Night Football and MLB picks at BetMGM Sportsbook with promo code CBSSPORTS and get up to $1,500 in bonus bets if your first bet loses: Nacua is questionable and expected to be a game-time decision when the Rams (0-1) host the New York Giants (1-0) at 8:15 p.m. ET on Monday Night Football at SoFi Stadium in Inglewood, Calif. The 25-year-old wideout, who led the NFL last season with 129 receptions, hauled in five passes for 74 yards in Los Angeles' Week 1 loss to San Francisco. Three-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year Donald is attempting a comeback after going into retirement following the 2023 season. The 35-year-old defensive end, who has registered 111 sacks in 154 career games, likely will receive limited playing time against the Giants . New York began its 2026 campaign with a 28-20 home triumph over the Dallas Cowboys as Jaxson Dart completed 23-of-29 pass attempts for 230 yards and three touchdowns. A pair of those scoring passes went to tight end Isaiah Likely , who was making his debut with the club after spending the first four years of his NFL career with the Baltimore Ravens under new Giants head coach John Harbaugh. Including two playoff meetings, the Rams are 30-17 against the Giants in the all-time series and have won the last four matchups. New York hasn't defeated Los Angeles since 2016, when it posted a 17-10 victory on the road to extend its winning streak in the series to seven games. There are only three games on Monday's MLB schedule as the league begins the final week of the regular season. One is the opener of a three-game series between a pair of American League East rivals as the Toronto Blue Jays (77-79) take on the Baltimore Orioles (75-81) at 6:35 p.m. ET at Camden Yards. The reigning AL champions Blue Jays, who have lost four of their last six contests, hope to keep alive their slim playoff hopes as they are three games behind the Chicago White Sox for the third wild card with six remaining. Baltimore has yet to be officially eliminated, but after a three-game sweep at the hands of the Milwaukee Brewers over the weekend, it trails Chicago by five games with six to play. Bet on Monday's NFL and MLB games with the FanDuel promo code and get up to $250 in bonus bets: The Detroit Tigers (73-83) kick off their season-ending six-game homestand with the opener of their three-game set against the Washington Nationals (73-83) at 6:40 p.m. ET at Comerica Park. Detroit has lost four of its last five contests, while Washington has won six of eight. The San Francisco Giants (64-92) also close out the year with six games at home, beginning with the first of three against the Minnesota Twins (73-83) at 9:45 p.m. ET at Oracle Park. San Francisco has gone 2-9 over its last 11 overall contests and Minnesota has won only six of its past 17 outings. The Rams are 6.5-point favorites against the Giants on Monday Night Football in the latest consensus NFL betting odds. The Orioles are -111 money line betting favorites against the Blue Jays in the latest consensus MLB betting odds and the Tigers are -136 betting favorites over the Nationals. The Twins are -122 favorites to beat the Giants at sports betting apps . Below is a snapshot of what to watch and bet for Monday, Sept. 21. All times Eastern Time: 8:15 p.m. | Location: Inglewood, Calif. | TV: ABC/ESPN | Stream: Fubo (Try for free) SportsLine picks -- Model : Rams -6.5 (-116) | Expert : Tyler Higbee Over 1.5 receptions (-102, R.J. White) The Rams h [... truncated ...]
Data comes from cached Sleeper and KTC snapshots. Values update when the sync jobs run.